• About Us
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Pickem Terms and Conditions
Tuesday, July 15, 2025
The Platte County Landmark Newspaper
  • Home
  • Local News
  • Opinion
  • Landmark Pickem!
    • Weekly Pickem Updates
    • Results by Week
    • The Leaderboard
    • Pickem Rules and Help
  • Landmark Live!
  • Looking Backward
  • es_MXSpanish
  • Home
  • Local News
  • Opinion
  • Landmark Pickem!
    • Weekly Pickem Updates
    • Results by Week
    • The Leaderboard
    • Pickem Rules and Help
  • Landmark Live!
  • Looking Backward
  • es_MXSpanish
No Result
View All Result
The Platte County Landmark Newspaper
No Result
View All Result

Proposal for 3-bed ER defeated at state level

Valerie Verkamp by Valerie Verkamp
September 29, 2023
in Headlines, Local News
Proposal for 3-bed ER defeated at state level
20
SHARES
494
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare via Email

WAS SOUGHT WEST OF HWY. 169 ALONG HWY. 152

In a very rare decision, the Missouri Health Facilities Review Committee has denied a request to build a standalone three-bed emergency care hospital just west of the Twin Creeks area. The location is in Clay County, just west of Hwy. 169 along Hwy. 152.

RelatedNews

Landmark On the Road–In Canada

Parkville chooses plan for easing congestion

Platte County Fair set July 23-26 in Tracy

The Missouri Health Facilities Review Committee denied the certificate of need on Tuesday, Sept. 12.

Of the 14 proposals reviewed by the committee, the Northland emergency care hospital was the only project that was rejected, and it was on a 3-2 vote.

On June 30, Richard Hill, attorney at law at Lashly & Baer, had submitted a 100-page certificate of need application on behalf of Northland Land Holding Company and Centerpoint Medical Center of Independence, which provided an overall picture of the community need for the proposed emergency health care services in the Northland.

In the application, the corporate entities contend that the average wait times at nearby hospital emergency rooms have surged to an average wait time of approximately 174 minutes.

In response to these wait times, Northland Land Holding and Centerpoint Medical Center of Independence were seeking approval from the Missouri Health Facilities Review Committee to construct a new surgical bed emergency care hospital to “meet the growing needs of the community.”

According to documents, the $37 million emergency care hospital with three medical beds would have occupied 5.5 acres west of the Twin Creeks area, which is bordered on the north by Interstate 435, on the south by Hwy. 152, on the west by Interstate 29, and on the east by Hwy. 169.

The main purpose of the 19,160-square-foot facility located at the intersection of North Holly Street and NW 88th Street would have been for strictly non-life-threatening emergency care, thereby reducing wait times at local hospital ERs.

The proposed emergency care hospital was projected to serve 7,664 patients in its first year of operation, 7,817 in its second year, and 7,974 in its third year.

Noted individuals and organizations that came out in favor of the proposed emergency care hospital included Congressman Emanuel Cleaver, State Sen. Lauren Arthur, State Rep. Maggie Nurrenbern, Kansas City Mayor Quinton Lucas, Kansas City Police Chief Stacey Graves, and chancellor of Metropolitan Community College Kimberly Beatty.

The proposed facility would have been distinctly different from the North Kansas City Hospital and Liberty Hospital because it lacks a Level 2 Trauma Center, which is fully equipped with seriously fast-track emergency services to handle life-threatening conditions.

In the certificate of need application, they make the argument that by 2025 about 1,325,348 people are estimated to live in the surrounding vicinity of the proposed emergency care hospital. Furthermore, they claim that the nearby hospitals have experienced overcrowding in their emergency departments, which can provoke adverse consequences for patients.

“The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) indicate that delays in getting care in an emergency department can reduce the quality of care and increase risks and discomfort of patients with serious illnesses or injuries,” stated the certificate of need application.

In their data analysis, the average wait time for all reported facilities in Missouri is 159 minutes, and the average wait time for facilities in surrounding states is 132, compared to the 174-minute wait time at the three nearest emergency departments to the proposed location.

Some observers believe that longer wait times can be attributed to the significant population growth in Clay County and Platte County. Larry Rideaux, Ed D, president of the Metropolitan Community College-Maple Woods Campus, wrote in a letter of support for Centerpoint Medical Center, “Platte County and Clay County, the two counties comprising a significant portion of the region, have experienced remarkable population growth of over 10 percent in the last ten years.

This new facility would fulfill a vital healthcare need and contribute to the economic growth of our region by creating job opportunities and attracting healthcare professionals and businesses.”

But critics of the standalone emergency care hospital say that the wait times showcased in the certificate of need do not adequately reflect the current situation.

In a system where wait times significantly fluctuated during the COVID-19 pandemic, many are quick to point out it is disingenuous to showcase patient wait times at the height of the COVID-19 pandemic.

“The wait time referenced in the application was from July 2021 to July 2022 and that was during the Delta and Omicron COVID surge,” said Dr. Steven Starr, a cardiologist specialist with Meritas Health Cardiology and interim chief medical officer at North Kansas City Hospital.

“This year, the average wait time at the North Kansas City Hospital is 15 minutes,” added Starr.

Wait time is calculated from when a patient enters the hospital until they are seen by a qualified medical professional. The ER is not a place where it is first come, first serve. Patients are triaged upon their arrival and are then ushered into a room to be seen by a medical physician in a priority-driven manner based on the severity of their medical complaint. Patients have no control over how long they will spend in the emergency room.

Although there is no easy formula to guide the Missouri Health Facilities Review Committee in determining where hospital facilities should be placed, many local health professionals contended the proposed emergency care hospital would have been too close to existing hospital facilities.

“As might be expected, “some of the concerns were that this proposed location was eight minutes from Saint Luke’s North Hospital, 14 minutes from the North Kansas City Hospital, and 18 minutes from Liberty Hospital,” said Starr.

Critics also contended that a three-bed standalone emergency room may not be fully equipped to handle severe life-threatening conditions, such as a stroke, heart attack, or emergency surgery situations. Patients suffering from these conditions would need to be transferred immediately. In such situations, this could be detrimental to the patient, critics contended.

A very similar project in Independence received the committee’s approval. From the point of view of Dr. Starr, the remarkable community response ultimately impacted the outcome for the proposal at Twin Creeks.

“There was an outpouring of opposition from hospitals, doctors, community leaders, and local politicians,” said Dr. Starr.

Tags: covid-19platte countyPublic Safety
Valerie Verkamp

Valerie Verkamp

Valerie decided she wanted to be a newspaper reporter when she was 28 years old and she successfully convinced the editor of the Platte County Landmark to give it 30 days. Now with The Landmark for over a decade, she has written countless stories on local government, education, lawsuits, community news, crime, and the prison system. Valerie hails from Park University with a BA in Elementary Education and a post-baccalaureate degree in paralegal studies from Penn Valley Community College. She has received honorable mention for Best Government News Story and joined her Landmark colleagues as recipient of the General Excellence Award in the Better Newspaper Contest sponsored by the Missouri Press Association.

Related Posts

Landmark On the Road

Landmark On the Road–In Canada

by Ivan Foley
July 10, 2025
0

Joe Wellington, former police chief for Platte City, poses in Yellowknife, Canada with a copy of The Landmark. Wellington and his group spent two weeks in Yellowknife, which is 2,500 miles north and west from Platte City. The group spent...

45 Years Ago–July 11, 1980

by Ivan Foley
July 9, 2025
0

A demolition derby on Wednesday, July 23 will be one of the spectator highlights of the 117th annual Platte County Fair, scheduled July 23-26 at the fairgrounds in Tracy. The derby will also be held Thursday. The fair will also...

30 Years Ago–July 13, 1995

by Ivan Foley
July 9, 2025
0

Eight girls are seeking the crown to be worn by the 1995 Platte County Fair Queen. Candidates include: Jennifer Cox, 17, sponsored by The Landmark Newspaper; Ginger Hass, 19, sponsored by Ida Cox; Ashley Jenks, 19, sponsored by Professional Eye...

15 Years Ago–July 14, 2010

by Ivan Foley
July 9, 2025
0

President Barack Obama visited Platte County’s Smith Electric Vehicles plant on Thursday as part of the administration’s wide ranging “Recovery Summer” tour of many of the stimulus projects funded by Recovery Act grants. Smith Electric Vehicles operates out of the...

Next Post
Evergy

Electrical reliability has shown significant improvement in Platte City

Popular News

  • Police

    Driver, 18, killed in Hwy. 45 crash

    113 shares
    Share 45 Tweet 28
  • Parkville chooses plan for easing congestion

    32 shares
    Share 13 Tweet 8
  • Platte City Lions Club has pulled the plug

    41 shares
    Share 16 Tweet 10
  • Nathan Willett says he’ll run for state senate

    12 shares
    Share 5 Tweet 3
  • Take survey about future of Downtown Platte City

    11 shares
    Share 4 Tweet 3
  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Pickem Terms and Conditions
Call us at 816-858-0363

Copyright © 2019-2020 The Platte County Landmark Newspaper - All Rights Reserved

No Result
View All Result
  • Subscribe Online
  • Home
  • Local News
  • Opinion
  • Landmark Pickem
    • Results by Week
    • The Leaderboard
    • Pickem Rules and Help
  • Landmark Live!
  • Looking Backward
  • es_MXSpanish

Copyright © 2019-2020 The Platte County Landmark Newspaper - All Rights Reserved