• About Us
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Pickem Terms and Conditions
Tuesday, September 26, 2023
The Platte County Landmark Newspaper
  • Home
  • Local News
  • Opinion
  • Landmark Pickem!
    • Weekly Pickem Updates
    • Login / Sign-up
    • Results by Week
    • The Leaderboard
    • Pickem Rules and Help
  • Landmark Live!
  • Looking Backward
  • es_MXSpanish
  • Home
  • Local News
  • Opinion
  • Landmark Pickem!
    • Weekly Pickem Updates
    • Login / Sign-up
    • Results by Week
    • The Leaderboard
    • Pickem Rules and Help
  • Landmark Live!
  • Looking Backward
  • es_MXSpanish
No Result
View All Result
The Platte County Landmark Newspaper
No Result
View All Result

‘Senseless and disturbing’

Debbie Coleman-Topi by Debbie Coleman-Topi
December 17, 2020
in Headlines
‘Senseless and disturbing’
59
SHARES
1.5k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare via Email

Sunshine Law experts comment on Parkville’s action in court case

The City of Parkville recently asked a Platte County judge to issue a “gag order” to silence a Parkville area resident who has filed suit against the city for withholding public documents. Two Missouri attorneys who specialize in Sunshine Law said silencing a citizen is counter to the purpose of the Sunshine Law, which is intended to safeguard government transparency and is a basic tenet of living in a democracy.

Area resident Jason Maki filed the suit against city officials in February, for withholding public documents he requested as a citizen. He complained to the court that the city has not even released basic information required as the two parties prepare for a court case in the matter.

RelatedNews

Subdivision of 225 homes gets early okay

Architects hired to assist detention center committee

Main Street Festival is Thursday

Maki has been seeking not only communications between city officials, but also how the aldermen, mayor and city administrator have searched for documents he has requested.

Attorneys Mark Pedroli and Bernie Rhodes said such a sanction in a Sunshine case is unprecedented and called it not only inappropriate, but also unconstitutional and counter to the law’s intended purpose.

“You can’t prohibit a citizen from complaining about their government,” Rhodes said during a recent telephone interview and added, “It’s the essence of the Constitution,” and he added that it is the very definition of a democracy.

Rhodes said the order would quash Maki’s right to free speech and asked, “Who are these people? It is beyond ridiculous. I’m sure the city has a lot better uses for their money,” he added, referring to the approximately $86,000 of taxpayer money the city reported it has already used in fighting the open records lawsuit, which isn’t close to wrapping up.

Rhodes, a member of Lathrop GPM of Kansas City and a lifelong Sunshine Law advocate, called the request “a lot of money being spent to protect somebody’s (city officials’) interests.”

He questioned the judgment of anyone from the city who felt this was appropriate and said a gag order is “completely contrary to what any first-year law student learns in Constitutional Law” class.

During a recent hearing Maki told the judge that city officials have failed to obey subpoenas to produce documents, concealed communications in those documents, and in some cases may have only performed perfunctory searches of documents in their possession versus fully complying with the subpoenas served upon them.

Maki asked the court to order the city officials to comply with the subpoenas and hold them in contempt for allegedly attempting to hide documents.

Paul F. Gordon, one of the five attorneys hired by the city to defend itself, responded by stating that the city officials may no longer possess the documents Maki is requesting, which raised concerns of possible destruction of evidence by the city officials (see accompanying Landmark article.)

As previously reported in The Landmark, current Parkville City Administrator Joe Parente was embroiled in a destruction of evidence controversy in his previous position in Illinois, according to media accounts.

Parkville Mayor Nan Johnston was found guilty by the Missouri Ethics Commission of concealing campaign donors and expenditures during her 2019 election campaign.

In response to Maki’s requests, and prior to the hearing, the City of Parkville attorneys filed a gag order request against Maki, which, if the judge imposes, would prevent him from speaking to the press about the case.

The proposed gag order also sought to prohibit Maki’s use of social media to communicate with people about the lawsuit.

Rhodes said the law distinguishes government officials at all levels, from national to state and local offices, as being separate from private citizens, who enjoy a constitutional right to privacy.

“These are elected officials,” he said. “If they don’t have a thick skin they never should have run for public office.”

Rhodes used recent media attention about Mayor Nan Johnston’s driving under the influence (DUI) arrest a few months ago as an example of how elected officials open themselves up to greater public scrutiny.

Numerous news outlets reported the mayor’s arrest and some local television news channels showed dash cam footage of the arrest. The footage showed the mayor’s telephone call, during the arrest, to Parkville Police Chief Kevin Chrisman.

“I’m sure she (Johnston) doesn’t want anyone to talk about her DUI arrest either,” said Rhodes, who has seen the newscasts.

Mark Pedroli, a St. Louis area attorney who specializes in Sunshine Law and operates the Sunshine and Government Accountability Project, agreed that a gag order is unfounded.

“Obviously the City of Parkville has lost the plot,” he said in an emailed statement. “It’s beyond alarming that a government entity would ask a court to gag a resident in Sunshine litigation,” he wrote.

“The city may not enjoy the litigation, but to ask a court to restrict First Amendment rights of a resident, in a judge-tried case, is both senseless and disturbing. Frankly, this highly unusual request makes you wonder what are they hiding in the City of Parkville?”

Sunshine experts, a Weston movie and writing quarters

Van Amburg indicates he’ll hang on to Sunshine case
Cities shouldn’t be allowed usage of a secret passageway
Tags: electionsethicsLawsuitsNan Johnstonparkvilleplatte countyPublic SafetySunshine Laws
Debbie Coleman-Topi

Debbie Coleman-Topi

Debbie’s journalism career officially began at the University of Missouri School of Journalism, where she was trained. Her works have appeared in the Kansas City Star and its former Sunday Magazine, the Independence Examiner and TWINS Magazine. Since 2016, Debbie has written for The Landmark, where she has reported on a wide range of Platte County area issues and people.

Related Posts

45 Years Ago–Sept. 22, 1978

by Ivan Foley
September 25, 2023
0

The Platte County Recorder of Deeds office has moved to the basement of the John R. Moore Law Building on Main Street in Platte City as of this week. Mark Mitchell of Huntsville, Ala., spent last weekend with his parents,...

30 Years Ago–Sept. 17, 1993

by Ivan Foley
September 25, 2023
0

Insurance coverage for the Zed Martin Day festival will be provided by the City of Platte City, thanks to a resolution passed by the city’s board of aldermen at a meeting Tuesday night. The annual Zed Martin Day celebration is...

15 Years Ago–Sept. 17, 2008

by Ivan Foley
September 25, 2023
0

The death of Valentin G. Kirilchuk, 39, of Springfield at the I-29 rest area south of Dearborn has been ruled a homicide by the Missouri State Highway Patrol. Kirilchuk was found on Monday, Sept. 8 in the men’s bathroom at...

Letter to the Editor

He sounds exasperated

by Landmark Digital
September 25, 2023
0

EDITOR: In your Between the Lines column last week (Sept. 13 edition), somehow you credit Plattsburg High School for Guy Speckman's choice of words as he used the word 'opulent' (in Ponder the Thought on page 3 of the same...

Next Post
Judge James Van Amburg retiring Dec. 31

Van Amburg indicates he'll hang on to Sunshine case

Popular News

  • Jack Stack Barbecue considering Platte County

    Jack Stack Barbecue considering Platte County

    97 shares
    Share 39 Tweet 24
  • Char Bar coming to Parkville

    124 shares
    Share 50 Tweet 31
  • Future of the courthouse

    15 shares
    Share 6 Tweet 4
  • Subdivision of 225 homes gets early okay

    6 shares
    Share 2 Tweet 2
  • Lawsuit claims toxic heavy metals in herbs and spices

    85 shares
    Share 34 Tweet 21
  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Pickem Terms and Conditions
Call us at 816-858-0363

Copyright © 2019-2020 The Platte County Landmark Newspaper - All Rights Reserved

No Result
View All Result
  • Subscribe Online
  • Home
  • Local News
  • Opinion
  • Landmark Pickem
    • Login / Sign-up
    • Results by Week
    • The Leaderboard
    • Pickem Rules and Help
  • Landmark Live!
  • Looking Backward
  • es_MXSpanish

Copyright © 2019-2020 The Platte County Landmark Newspaper - All Rights Reserved