• About Us
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Pickem Terms and Conditions
Wednesday, June 7, 2023
The Platte County Landmark Newspaper
  • Home
  • Local News
  • Opinion
  • Landmark Pickem!
    • Weekly Pickem Updates
    • Results by Week
    • The Leaderboard
    • Pickem Rules and Help
  • Landmark Live!
  • Looking Backward
  • es_MXSpanish
  • Home
  • Local News
  • Opinion
  • Landmark Pickem!
    • Weekly Pickem Updates
    • Results by Week
    • The Leaderboard
    • Pickem Rules and Help
  • Landmark Live!
  • Looking Backward
  • es_MXSpanish
No Result
View All Result
The Platte County Landmark Newspaper
No Result
View All Result

Van Amburg indicates he’ll hang on to Sunshine case

Debbie Coleman-Topi by Debbie Coleman-Topi
December 17, 2020
in Headlines
Judge James Van Amburg retiring Dec. 31
14
SHARES
354
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare via Email

Plans to hear it while serving as a senior judge

During a recent hearing in a case in which a Parkville area resident is suing the city for withholding requested public documents, the presiding county court judge indicated he plans to continue hearing arguments in the case after his upcoming retirement.

Platte County Judge James Van Amburg said during a hearing Friday in Jason Maki vs. City of Parkville that he hopes to see the case through to the end despite his plans to retire effective at the end of the month. After his retirement, he will assume senior judge status.

RelatedNews

Fender bender preceded fatal Northmoor shooting

Landmark English Award

Man weed eating yard killed in alleged DWI crash

“My replacement hasn’t been named yet,” the judge said from the bench near the close of a hearing on Friday.

Both sides–the plaintiff Maki and the defendant’s attorney in court on Friday–said they hoped Van Amburg would be the judge to continue to hear the case.

Friday’s hearing came after recent filings in the case in which Maki asked the judge to find city officials in contempt of court for “not acting in good faith by their failure to produce” during pre-trial information-seeking. Paul Gordon of the city’s law firm of Baty Otto Coronado argued finding officials in contempt is inappropriate and too extreme.

In response, attorneys for the city recently asked the judge to impose a “gag order” on Maki to prevent him from speaking to the press or social media sites during the trial. Gag orders are common during criminal proceedings, not civil lawsuits. (See related Landmark article about this topic.)

During the Friday hearing, Van Amburg said he plans to rule soon on several motions in the case, in which Maki claims city officials are illegally withholding documents that should be forthcoming under the Sunshine Law, which is intended to guarantee government transparency for citizens.

When Van Amburg mentioned, during the hearing, the possibility of setting a summer trial date, Maki, said: “We are almost a year into this and I am still waiting for the city to respond to discovery request made last March,” referring to an early phase of a trial in which both sides seek basic information. Maki has said city leaders not only have withheld documents he requested under Sunshine, but also have not supplied information during the discovery phase of the lawsuit and has filed court motions intended to force the city to produce such information.

Van Amburg said he might review the case in late January or early February to set a trial date. He acknowledged he has yet not issued judgment in a few issues of the case which he has heard during the past several months.

“I understand I’m a couple of orders behind and will try to act on those promptly,” he said, referring to recent hearings in which he took issues “under advisement.”

At a hearing in November, Maki told the court that the city is stalling in attempts to avoid producing correspondence they do not want made public.

During the most recent hearing regarding the city official’s alleged attempts to disobey a court subpoena, Gordon said city officials “complied with the subpoenas and produced everything they had.” Maki disputed Gordon’s claims and produced numerous examples to prove otherwise and asked the court to hold the city’s officials in contempt.

Gordon responded, “You can’t hold them in contempt for something they don’t have,” he said, implying the documents may no longer exist.

Maki went on to state that the city officials were obligated to retain correspondences for use in possible future litigation starting when they first became aware of the Missouri Attorney General’s intent to investigate the city in January 2019.

But Gordon took exception. “There’s no law that these are all to be preserved,” he said.

Maki, a pro se litigant without any formal legal training, cited previous case law demonstrating that the city’s officials did have a “duty to preserve” and that their actions may open the door into questions regarding destruction of evidence.

Maki also provided examples of city officials’ production of documents when he said several of them had produced the same document with the exact same formatting, type face, spacing, etc., even though they all used different computing devices and printers. In other words, he believes officials simply photocopied a single same document and handed it over as if it were from their computers versus actually searching their own emails.

Gordon accused Maki of “ulterior motives,” stating that Maki “files a motion knowing the media will pick it up.”

Gordon claimed Maki has animosity toward city officials and mentioned a Facebook page operated by citizens who object to the way the city is managed. He mentioned “Citizens for a Better Parkville” a Political Action Committee (PAC) whose members post messages that sometimes show public officials in a negative light.

“He (Maki) is not looking for sanctions,” he said. “He’s looking for headlines.”

Gordon asked Van Amburg to impose sanctions (fines) on Maki to cover the city attorneys’ fees in responding to this most recent motion in addition to the proposed “gag order.”

“These are part-time politicians, with their own lives,” he said, adding that he objects to Maki’s request that the judge hold city officials in contempt of court for not producing the documents.

‘Senseless and disturbing’

Judge is asked to hold Parkville officials in contempt

Sunshine experts, a Weston movie and writing quarters
Tags: Lawsuitsparkvilleplatte countySunshine Laws
Debbie Coleman-Topi

Debbie Coleman-Topi

Debbie’s journalism career officially began at the University of Missouri School of Journalism, where she was trained. Her works have appeared in the Kansas City Star and its former Sunday Magazine, the Independence Examiner and TWINS Magazine. Since 2016, Debbie has written for The Landmark, where she has reported on a wide range of Platte County area issues and people.

Related Posts

Letter to the Editor

Get public input on future of Parkville’s Ethics Commission

by Landmark Digital
June 4, 2023
0

EDITOR: I am writing to share an article (below) which was recently posted on a local citizens group website. I believe this information urgently needs to be brought to the attention of our Parkville area residents. I am a fervent...

Fender bender preceded fatal Northmoor shooting

Fender bender preceded fatal Northmoor shooting

by Landmark Digital
June 3, 2023
0

VICTIM WAS SHOT FROM JUST INCHES AWAY The Platte County Prosecutor's Office has filed charges against Phillip J. Frazier, age 50, of Northmoor, in the death of Cody J. Steffen, 32, also of Northmoor, which is located in southern Platte...

45 Years Ago–June 9, 1978

by Ivan Foley
June 2, 2023
0

Douglas Lee Barton of Platte City was selected for the Leavenworth Eagles Area 55 All-Star team which took second place in the Fort Leavenworth Tournament on June 4. The Eagles defeated the Liberty Merchants 8-4 on May 29 and advanced...

30 Years Ago–May 28, 1993

by Ivan Foley
June 2, 2023
0

Karen Seckel was hired as the new principal at North Platte Elementary School at Camden Point. “I was pleased that we have a qualified candidate within the school district. She is a quality individual,” said Dr. Francis Moran, R-1 superintendent....

Next Post

15 Years Ago--December 15, 2005

Popular News

  • Chaves Development at Ambassador Building

    Development coming near Ambassador Building

    196 shares
    Share 78 Tweet 49
  • Fender bender preceded fatal Northmoor shooting

    55 shares
    Share 22 Tweet 14
  • Park Hill student killed in crash

    42 shares
    Share 17 Tweet 11
  • Born at just over 1.5 pounds, Baby Van home after 139 days

    26 shares
    Share 10 Tweet 7
  • Man weed eating yard killed in alleged DWI crash

    17 shares
    Share 7 Tweet 4
  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Pickem Terms and Conditions
Call us at 816-858-0363

Copyright © 2019-2020 The Platte County Landmark Newspaper - All Rights Reserved

No Result
View All Result
  • Subscribe Online
  • Home
  • Local News
  • Opinion
  • Landmark Pickem
    • Login / Sign-up
    • Results by Week
    • The Leaderboard
    • Pickem Rules and Help
  • Landmark Live!
  • Looking Backward
  • es_MXSpanish

Copyright © 2019-2020 The Platte County Landmark Newspaper - All Rights Reserved