• About Us
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
Wednesday, March 3, 2021
51 °f
Platte
47 ° Fri
48 ° Sat
52 ° Sun
54 ° Mon
The Platte County Landmark Newspaper
  • Home
  • Local News
  • Opinion
  • Landmark Live!
  • Looking Backward
  • Home
  • Local News
  • Opinion
  • Landmark Live!
  • Looking Backward
No Result
View All Result
The Platte County Landmark Newspaper
No Result
View All Result

Judge orders city to respond to requests for discovery

Debbie Coleman-Topi by Debbie Coleman-Topi
February 19, 2021
in Headlines
12
SHARES
289
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare via Email

Latest in the Sunshine lawsuit vs. Parkville

On a recent motion to compel in a lawsuit against Parkville, a Platte County judge sided in favor of Jason Maki, a citizen who is suing the City of Parkville for alleged violations of the state’s Sunshine Law.

If Maki is successful in his lawsuit, the City of Parkville could be fined in excess of $300,000, not including any legal fees awarded to Maki by the court.

RelatedNews

Judge tells city to produce documents

Volunteer coordinator to aid local vaccination clinics

Northland Soccer complex approved by KC

Parkville’s legal costs in this matter have already surpassed $100,000.

Judge James Van Amburg ordered that the City of Parkville to fully respond to multiple discovery requests filed by Maki. Maki had previously asked the court to order the city to answer his questions after the city refused to answer his requests for discovery.

Parkville’s team of attorneys objected on several grounds, including that Maki’s questions were unduly burdensome. However, in a ruling dated Feb. 9, the judge overruled the city’s arguments and gave the City of Parkville 10 days, or until Friday, Feb. 19, to provide Maki the requested information.

During the case, Maki has maintained that the city and its team of lawyers have failed to provide him information he has requested despite a judge ordering the information’s release during a hearing this past August.

In one hearing, Judge Van Amburg told Steve Coronado, one of the city-hired attorneys, that Maki “is entitled to that information and I want it provided to him.” Coronado stated he would respond to items requested “to the extent that we have the information on it.”

Van Amburg said Maki should be apprised of the processes that city officials have used to respond to his Sunshine requests. Specifically, those processes include search terms used, amounts charged and how fees were calculated. During that hearing, Coronado again replied “understood,” but according to court documents the information was never provided.

City’s Responses to Date Have Been Evasive

One of Maki’s Sunshine requests asked for communications between city officials and members of the press. His lawsuit claims that the city withheld hundreds of the communications sought from the public. In the court documents, the city responded that a “technical error of some type” led to the documents being withheld from Maki.

Maki has since requested that the city “describe in detail” the city’s alleged “technical error of some type.” Attorneys for the city objected to answering Maki’s request as they feel it is “vague, ambiguous and argumentative” and would require speculation, “as to facts being sought…”

The judge agreed with Maki’s assessment that the city’s descriptions of the technical error that led to information being withheld was “incomplete or evasive” and has ordered the city to answer Maki’s question.

In other information requested, Maki asked the city to describe the process the city uses in maintaining the identities of property and their owners including the methods by which the city determines where to send sewer bills.

The city’s response was: “The city doesn’t maintain a list.”

The city’s legal team also objected to Maki’s question as being “broad and unduly burdensome” and that it would require “a narrative response” that would require the defendant to “guess and to speculate” regarding the information being sought. Maki responded that “interrogatories naturally seek some narrative form response,” and that the city is not overly burdened by providing such information.

The final interrogatory to which the city’s legal defense objected, asks for the city to identify anyone that the city officials or staff have “discussed” topics “concerning” Maki’s records requests. The interrogatory specifically requests the city to identify members and officers of boards, commissions, political subdivisions, and quasi-governmental groups, including members of Community Improvement Districts (CIDs) with whom Maki’s requests were “discussed.”

The city’s attorneys claimed that the words “concerning” and “discussed” are overly broad and require speculation “as to their meaning” and that Maki’s question “seeks information not relevant to this case (and) not likely to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence.”

Maki responded by stating that the terms are commonly used in the English language, are not overly broad, and “do not require the city to speculate.”

In summation, Maki’s court filing stated, that the City of Parkville has evaded “its duty to make legal records available to Mr. Maki that he requested under the Sunshine Law” and by refusing to answer the questions “is acting evasively, demonstrating conscious and intentional disregard for the discovery process and the court’s prior rulings in the case.”

The filing continues that “the city’s blanket, boilerplate, and nonspecific objections are unfounded and do not apply to Mr. Maki’s interrogatories.”

The latest court hearing in the case was Jan. 25, and another was scheduled for Monday, Feb. 8, but was canceled, presumably due to weather. Another date has not yet been set.

Tags: Lawsuitsparkvilleplatte countySunshine Laws
Debbie Coleman-Topi

Debbie Coleman-Topi

Debbie's journalism career began at the University of Missouri School of Journalism, where she was trained.

Her works have appeared in The Kansas City Star and its Sunday magazine, The (Independence) Examiner and TWINS Magazine. Debbie has written for The Landmark for the past four years where she has reported on a wide range of Platte County area issues and people.

These include the longest-running issue of her three-decade career--a massive development in Parkville, which spawned a citizens' movement that objects to the way city officials manage the city.

She is the author of "TWINformation: The Biology, Psychology and Development of Twins”, written in response to having and raising fraternal male twins (she and her husband later welcomed a girl to the family.)

She is also the author of “Memories of A War Bride,” which chronicles the life of her husband's Godmother, a WWII English war bride.

Debbie and her husband, John, live in Blue Springs, a long car drive from events and meetings she covers for The Landmark. In fact, when she first met publisher Ivan Foley, after answering his ad for a reporter she told him she should have packed a lunch for the long journey. When she heard no response following the job interview, Debbie called to ask if Foley was not interested in her joining the staff. He was interested, but assumed the drive was too long.

Obviously, he was wrong.

Related Posts

Judge James Van Amburg

Judge tells city to produce documents

by Debbie Coleman-Topi
March 3, 2021
0

Discovery items that have been withheld from Maki A Platte County judge took action Monday in an ongoing dispute in which a private citizen is suing the City of Parkville for violations of the state's open meetings and records law,...

Mass vaccination Riverside

Volunteer coordinator to aid local vaccination clinics

by Ivan Foley
March 2, 2021
0

Up to $25,000 in federal CARES dollars will be used to hire a volunteer coordinator for the mass vaccination operations of the Platte County Health Department. Working with the Platte County Emergency Management Organization (EMO), which is an arm of...

45 Years Ago–March 12, 1976

by Ivan Foley
March 1, 2021
0

Robert C. Ham of Parkville recently was presented a watch for 30 years of service at Western Electric and Mrs. Ham was presented a pin in honor of the occasion. The Park Hill Acapella Choir will present their 24th annual...

30 Years Ago–March 8, 1991

by Ivan Foley
March 1, 2021
0

The Platte County R-3 High School Concert and Jazz Bands will present a concert Thursday, March 14. The program, under the direction of Wendell Doyle, will feature two selections which the concert bands will be performing at the district music...

Next Post
Pitchers and catchers

Pitchers and catchers report

Popular News

  • Why the urgency for R-3 bond issue?

    Why the urgency for R-3 bond issue?

    26 shares
    Share 10 Tweet 7
  • Around 1,700 shots to be offered in the next week

    17 shares
    Share 7 Tweet 4
  • City ‘finds’ 2,300 records, gives them to Jason Maki

    16 shares
    Share 6 Tweet 4
  • Investigations, rolling outages and building south

    9 shares
    Share 4 Tweet 2
  • Attorney general probing Parkville on Sunshine

    9 shares
    Share 4 Tweet 2
  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
Call us at 816-858-0363

Copyright © 2019-2020 The Platte County Landmark Newspaper - All Rights Reserved

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Subscribe Online
  • Local News
  • Opinion
  • Landmark Live!
  • Looking Backward

Copyright © 2019-2020 The Platte County Landmark Newspaper - All Rights Reserved

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Create New Account!

Fill the forms bellow to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist