• About Us
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Pickem Terms and Conditions
Wednesday, May 18, 2022
The Platte County Landmark Newspaper
  • Home
  • Local News
  • Opinion
  • Landmark Pickem!
    • Login / Sign-up
    • Results by Week
    • Pickem Rules and Help
  • Landmark Live!
  • Looking Backward
  • es_MXSpanish
  • Home
  • Local News
  • Opinion
  • Landmark Pickem!
    • Login / Sign-up
    • Results by Week
    • Pickem Rules and Help
  • Landmark Live!
  • Looking Backward
  • es_MXSpanish
No Result
View All Result
The Platte County Landmark Newspaper
No Result
View All Result

Platte City’s $325,000 payment settles lawsuit

PJ Rooks by PJ Rooks
January 1, 2012
in Platte City
4
SHARES
92
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare via Email

A breach of contract lawsuit filed by Rose-Lan Contractors Inc. against Platte City was “dismissed with prejudice” on Dec. 8 by Senior United States District Judge Scott Wright of the Western District of Missouri, St. Joseph Division.

Both parties will assume responsibility for their own legal fees and the term “with prejudice” indicates that neither will be allowed to file the case again.

RelatedNews

Work begins at I-29 and Hwy. 92

Car shows set in Platte City

REAL ID enforcement pushed back to 2023

Mike Callahan, a partner in the construction law practice of Stinson, Morrison and Hecker L.L.P. and attorney for Rose-Lan Contractors, said that the city and Rose-Lan had reached a settlement resolving the dispute and the Rose-Lan dismissed the case in return for payment of roughly $325,000 from the city.

“Damages initially sought exceeded probably north of one million dollars,” said Callahan. “Part of it was the direct impact of the site conditions and part of it was the loss of Rose-Lan’s future business.”

Callahan said that shortly before Thanksgiving, Rose-Lan filed another suit for the remainder of the damages against Bartlett and West, the engineering firm retained by Platte City to compile the original pre-bid documents on which the Rose-Lan price was based.

“That company (Rose-Lan) was essentially put out of business as a result of this job,” said Callahan. “All the employees were let go and I think the owner took an earlier than planned retirement.”

Public records located previously by The Landmark showed Rose-Lan as having carried an annual payroll between $1 and $2.5 million with approximately 20 employees and $6.8 million in sales in 2009.

The original case against the city was filed on Sept. 7, 2010 regarding a dispute over the consistency of the clay in which Rose-Lan had been hired to install 4,500 feet of 24-inch sewer pipe along Platte River between 92 Highway and the sewage treatment plant.

With 500 feet completed, Rose-Lan claimed that the soil in the area was not “fatty clay,” as described in the pre-bid documents, but instead “silty clay” with too much water content. Maintaining that it could not complete or guarantee the work without a change order from the city accommodating both the changes in physical conditions and increased costs of construction, Rose-Lan evacuated the job site in the summer of 2010 after the city declined its change order request on the grounds that the clay was not too wet to continue as originally planned.

City crews led by Public Works Director Leonard Hendricks later successfully installed 602 feet of the sewer pipe and two manholes at a depth of 40 feet or more.

Rose-Lan president Bill Persons was not available for comment on the dismissal of the case but said in a previous interview with The Landmark that he had been advised by the pipe company not to install the pipe in the given conditions.

“I didn’t just walk off (the job),” said Persons. “We had several people look at it before we made that decision. When the pipe company tells you that they don’t want their pipe put in that the way it’s designed, you don’t have much choice.”

Callahan said that with respect to the city, he is glad the case is resolved.

“The city and the taxpayers have better things to do with regard to litigation,” he said.

D.J. Gehrt, city administrator for Platte City, said that now that it is free to continue the sewer line project, and with about half of the work yet to be completed, the city will consider three possible approaches for moving forward.

First, he said, the city can put public works crews back on the job to complete the rest of the project.

“The advantage of that is that we trust the quality of our public works folks,” said Gehrt. “The disadvantage is that it is a relatively large construction project. Although we can and have done construction projects, (our public works department) is not set up to do that.”

It would also take public works crews away from other tasks, he said.

A second option would be to use a “station-to-station bid.” The pipe, Gehrt said, has been completed at both the north and south ends with the middle remaining to be installed so a “station-to-station” bid would entail hiring a second contractor to complete the work as described in the original bid documents.

The third option, said Gehrt, would be to restart the design and bidding processes from scratch as a new job defined as a station-to-station project.

The difference between the second and third options, he explained, is that the second would involve the use of the original plans and specifications while the third would begin the entire process anew as a separate and distinct project.

“One of the issues of this lawsuit with Rose-Lan (was that) Rose-Lan accused the city of not adequately describing the soil conditions,” Gehrt explained. “Since the plans and specifications, and the conditions describing the specifications, were part of the issue, we don’t want to get back into that situation. So we have to be real careful both on the legal and engineering side that everyone is satisfied with those plans and specifications. Obviously if we feel there is a problem, (we can) go through the geo-engineering work again and make sure everyone is extremely comfortable with the conditions we state.”

Gehrt said that the city feels that the fatty clay description was correct but plans to ensure that the same thing cannot happen again.

“We want to make sure that anyone who is moving forward with this project on the contractor side knows what they’re getting into and more importantly does not have a recourse to say that anyone misled them in not adequately describing the soil conditions,” said Gehrt.

Gehrt explained that in fulfillment of American Recovery and Reinvestment Act requirements for the sewer line, Bartlett and West was separately retained as the city’s engineering firm for the project but was, at the same time, contracted as the city’s on-call engineering firm as well.

The city has since contracted with Shafer, Kline and Warren as its on-call engineering service provider, however, while Bartlett and West continues to serve as engineer for the sewer line project.

Gehrt said that if the city were to choose the third option of beginning the project again from scratch, a new request for proposals would go out for a project engineer and, he said, “If Bartlett and West had the best proposal again, they would be selected again.”

Tags: lawsuitLawsuitsplatte cityplatte county
PJ Rooks

PJ Rooks

Related Posts

45 Years Ago–May 13, 1977

by Ivan Foley
May 13, 2022
0

Dr. Carl Myers purchase the Platte Medical Clinic in Platte City this week and plans to open his office here in the near future. Dr. Nourbaksh will continue to be located in the Platte Medical Clinic. Mr. and Mrs. Louis...

30 Years Ago–May 15, 1992

by Ivan Foley
May 13, 2022
0

Bob Foster, vice principal of Fort Osage Junior High in northeast Independence, has been hired as principal at West Platte High School in Weston. Two girls tied with the same grade point average have been declared valedictorians of the class...

15 Years Ago–May 9, 2007

by Ivan Foley
May 13, 2022
0

It has been a hectic week for Platte County residents and business owners with property in low-lying areas, as heavy rains across the region have forced rivers and streams out of their banks. Areas in and around Parkville, Riverside, Tracy...

The 80's

Kim Carnes and never buy gas on Tuesdays

by Ivan Foley
May 13, 2022
0

Gonna hit you with some pop culture stuff this week. Just because I want to. Season four of Ozark on Netflix. Have you finished it yet? Let's get through this without spoiling it for those who haven't made it all...

Next Post

Zahnd proposes solution to county budget woes

Popular News

  • Area distillery releases first new bourbon in 30 years

    Area distillery releases first new bourbon in 30 years

    22 shares
    Share 9 Tweet 6
  • Bee Creek Bridge replacement set

    10 shares
    Share 4 Tweet 3
  • Large logistics park planned east of I-29

    198 shares
    Share 79 Tweet 50
  • Memorial Day Weekend Celebration planned

    7 shares
    Share 3 Tweet 2
  • City extends lease on temporary police station

    7 shares
    Share 3 Tweet 2
  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Pickem Terms and Conditions
Call us at 816-858-0363

Copyright © 2019-2020 The Platte County Landmark Newspaper - All Rights Reserved

No Result
View All Result
  • Subscribe Online
  • Home
  • Local News
  • Opinion
  • Landmark Pickem
    • Results by Week
    • Pickem Rules and Help
  • Landmark Live!
  • Looking Backward
  • es_MXSpanish

Copyright © 2019-2020 The Platte County Landmark Newspaper - All Rights Reserved

Are you sure want to unlock this post?
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?