• About Us
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
Monday, April 19, 2021
41 °f
Platte
39 ° Tue
40 ° Wed
43 ° Thu
52 ° Fri
The Platte County Landmark Newspaper
  • Home
  • Local News
  • Opinion
  • Landmark Live!
  • Looking Backward
  • Home
  • Local News
  • Opinion
  • Landmark Live!
  • Looking Backward
No Result
View All Result
The Platte County Landmark Newspaper
No Result
View All Result

Judge tells city to produce documents

Debbie Coleman-Topi by Debbie Coleman-Topi
March 3, 2021
in Headlines
Judge James Van Amburg

Judge James Van Amburg

29
SHARES
715
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare via Email

Discovery items that have been withheld from Maki

A Platte County judge took action Monday in an ongoing dispute in which a private citizen is suing the City of Parkville for violations of the state’s open meetings and records law, commonly known as the Sunshine Law.

Judge James Van Amburg determined that the City of Parkville has waived its attorney-client privileges related to its discussions regarding Jason Maki’s Sunshine requests.

RelatedNews

Smoke and fire

Major addition set at Zona Rosa

Landmark Award winner

In doing so, the judge also denied the city’s request that he reconsider a court order issued Feb. 9 requiring the city to fully answer Maki’s discovery questions.

In addition during Monday’s hearing, the judge ordered the City of Parkville to produce all of the documents sought under discovery that have been withheld from Maki.

The hearing included Maki, who is representing himself and two attorneys on behalf of the city, Steven Coronado and Paul Gordon, of the law firm Baty Otto Coronado of Kansas City.

Multiple times during the hearing Parkville’s attorneys attacked Maki’s motives.

“He just wants to punish these people,” Gordon said, referring to the city and adding that Maki is making certain arguments just “to get headlines.”

In response, Van Amburg said, “This is the third time I’ve heard about the newspaper, which is pretty irrelevant to the legal arguments we’re making here today,” seeming to indicate to Parkville’s attorneys that they needed to move past their attacks on Maki.

“Understood,” Gordon and Coronado both said in response to the judge’s comment.

Van Amburg also heard additional arguments regarding the failure of the Parkville mayor and aldermen to produce requested communications sought via subpoena by Maki. The city’s legal team argued that instructions made by the Missouri Attorney General, who began investigating the city in 2019 on the basis of Sunshine violations, to retain documents for future possible litigation did not apply to the elected aldermen and mayor, especially when, as in this case, communications are conducted on private devices.

“There’s no legal basis to say they are all under an obligation to save them, especially if it’s not in the city’s possession,” said Stephen Coronado.

“I don’t think that’s any reason to hold them in contempt of court,” Gordon said and added that Maki has no evidence aldermen possess additional documents.

In retort, Maki provided the court multiple forms of exhibits as evidence of documents that should have been produced by the elected officials through subpoena but were not.

Gordon said if the attorney general and Maki wanted individual aldermen to retain such communications on private devices they should have sent retention requests to each alderman, but instead only addressed the matter to city officials as a group.

In addition, Gordon said it’s reasonable to expect individuals, such as the aldermen to delete emails. Maki pointed out to the court that the Parkville elected officials had “brazenly flaunted their use of private email communications to conduct public business” to the Missouri Attorney General during its 2019 investigation and that the city’s duty to preserve records for future litigation extended to the mayor and aldermen’s private communications, as the city had sanctioned its use of private communication services for public business.

Van Amburg seemed to summarize with Maki’s claim that elected officials fall under the same obligation as city staff when he said, “there’s separation between ordinary citizens as compared with someone issuing policies (elected officials such as aldermen).”

Maki asked the judge to find city officials in contempt of court for failing to produce documents they had in their possession and otherwise had a legal duty to retain. The legal team told Van Amburg that a contempt order is an extreme measure and should not apply in this case.

The judge took under advisement Maki’s request and said he will rule on the matter within the next 10 days or by Thursday, March 11.

RELATED ARTICLES:

Van Amburg indicates he’ll hang on to Sunshine case

Tags: Nan Johnstonparkvilleplatte countySunshine Laws
Debbie Coleman-Topi

Debbie Coleman-Topi

Debbie's journalism career began at the University of Missouri School of Journalism, where she was trained.

Her works have appeared in The Kansas City Star and its Sunday magazine, The (Independence) Examiner and TWINS Magazine. Debbie has written for The Landmark for the past four years where she has reported on a wide range of Platte County area issues and people.

These include the longest-running issue of her three-decade career--a massive development in Parkville, which spawned a citizens' movement that objects to the way city officials manage the city.

She is the author of "TWINformation: The Biology, Psychology and Development of Twins”, written in response to having and raising fraternal male twins (she and her husband later welcomed a girl to the family.)

She is also the author of “Memories of A War Bride,” which chronicles the life of her husband's Godmother, a WWII English war bride.

Debbie and her husband, John, live in Blue Springs, a long car drive from events and meetings she covers for The Landmark. In fact, when she first met publisher Ivan Foley, after answering his ad for a reporter she told him she should have packed a lunch for the long journey. When she heard no response following the job interview, Debbie called to ask if Foley was not interested in her joining the staff. He was interested, but assumed the drive was too long.

Obviously, he was wrong.

Related Posts

Vehicle fire

Smoke and fire

by Landmark Digital Staff
April 19, 2021
0

A vehicle fire produced smoke seen from a great distance along southbound Interstate 29 in northern Platte County on Monday. Members of the Camden Point Fire Department and Dearborn Area Fire Protection District responded to the scene to extinguish the...

Missouri Riverfront Trail

Trail connection celebrated

by Landmark Digital Staff
April 16, 2021
0

Riverside Mayor Kathy Rose, center, cut the ribbon along with Parkville Mayor Nan Johnston (left) and Platte County Commissioner Dagmar Wood (right) to note the opening of a connection of the Missouri Riverfront Trail between Riverside and Parkville. Years in...

Emilia Wisniewski

Landmark Award winner

by Ivan Foley
April 16, 2021
0

Emilia Wisniewski, senior at Platte County R-3 High School, is this year's winner of The Landmark English Award. Emilia is destined for Boston University to study journalism, with goals including to work as investigative journalist post-college and eventually write and...

Proposed sewer rate hike nixed on split vote

Proposed sewer rate hike nixed on split vote

by Debbie Coleman-Topi
April 15, 2021
0

Parkville mayor forced to break tie A proposal to raise sewer rates for residents who use the Parkville sewer system failed during a board of aldermen meeting last Tuesday. The measure, which called for raising rates by six percent, followed...

Next Post
Parkville police car

Criminal activity rises by 16% in Parkville

Popular News

  • Parkville Speakeasy

    A Parkville speakeasy; slow-paced courtroom drama

    29 shares
    Share 12 Tweet 7
  • Judge tells city attorney ‘put case on front burner’

    23 shares
    Share 9 Tweet 6
  • Major subdivision planned along Crooked Road

    43 shares
    Share 17 Tweet 11
  • Major addition set at Zona Rosa

    18 shares
    Share 7 Tweet 5
  • Ball field talk gets heated at Parkville

    14 shares
    Share 6 Tweet 4
  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
Call us at 816-858-0363

Copyright © 2019-2020 The Platte County Landmark Newspaper - All Rights Reserved

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Subscribe Online
  • Local News
  • Opinion
  • Landmark Live!
  • Looking Backward

Copyright © 2019-2020 The Platte County Landmark Newspaper - All Rights Reserved

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist