• About Us
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Pickem Terms and Conditions
Wednesday, May 18, 2022
The Platte County Landmark Newspaper
  • Home
  • Local News
  • Opinion
  • Landmark Pickem!
    • Login / Sign-up
    • Results by Week
    • Pickem Rules and Help
  • Landmark Live!
  • Looking Backward
  • es_MXSpanish
  • Home
  • Local News
  • Opinion
  • Landmark Pickem!
    • Login / Sign-up
    • Results by Week
    • Pickem Rules and Help
  • Landmark Live!
  • Looking Backward
  • es_MXSpanish
No Result
View All Result
The Platte County Landmark Newspaper
No Result
View All Result

To re-open or not to re-open?

Landmark Staff by Landmark Staff
April 22, 2020
in Letters to the Editor
6
SHARES
149
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare via Email

EDITOR:

How should we decide if the economy should be reopened ASAP, or if we should continue waiting for testing, a vaccine, etc?

RelatedNews

Letters to the Editor: Control of my body

New KCI and its future impact on the cost to fly

‘Defund the police’ is a nothing slogan

I believe the most relevant questions and information are:

QUESTION NO. 1. What justified the shut down and has that situation resolved?

QUESTION NO. 2. What are the costs and benefits of the two options – opening up now or not opening up now (waiting until some future time or when additional criteria are met)?

ANSWER NO. 1. The reason given for shutting down was that we had to flatten the curve so that hospitals didn’t get overwhelmed. It was not about reducing the number of people who eventually got infected, but slowing it down so that they could all be taken care of. If hospitals were overwhelmed and didn’t have enough ventilators, personnel, ICU beds, etc, people could die because they could not get care when they needed it.

I don’t believe there is anywhere in the country where hospitals are currently overwhelmed. Places like NYC that, early on, had too many patients to take care of at one time are now in good shape, I believe. The reason we were given for having to shut down the economy has been resolved. (To the extent there are any hospitals that are overwhelmed now, perhaps their economy should not be opened up just yet for that reason.)

The shut down decisions were made without full information about what would happen, how many people would get infected, how sick they would get, what treatments would be effective, etc. We can’t wait for perfect information. However, we are learning that the projections that were used to inform shut down decisions were very far off from what is actually playing out. The assumptions that went into the projection models, although perhaps well-intentioned, were quite flawed. That is not to say that models are always bad but it can be very hard to peg many of the assumptions, and so we should use projections with a big dose of caution.

In my view, the flawed projections probably made it more likely that shut downs would be ordered than if we’d had more accurate projections, because the projections dramatically overstated the effects of the virus – even by several times or more. Some people have concluded that shut downs were not warranted except perhaps in the worst hot spots (I have not looked at their data and reasoning in detail yet). The other thing that’s relevant here is that Sweden did not do a shut down at all. Swedes have been going about their business as usual. The last information I looked at said their death rate from the coronavirus is only slightly higher as a percent of their population than their neighbors who shut down their economies.

All of this leads me to conclude that we should strongly consider ending the shut down and opening the country back up now, as any reason that existed to justify the shut down has been resolved, and it may not have even been a good idea in the first place. The other thing to look at is to compare costs and benefits of re-opening now vs staying shut down.

ANSWER NO. 2: The most important thing to remember here is that when you pick an option, you get both the benefits and costs associated with that option. You cannot just take the benefits and ignore the costs. I know everybody knows this, but it’s easy to focus only on the benefits of shut down if you listen to the constant drum beat of reports about deaths, infections and hospitalizations from the virus. But you can’t shut down the economy without impacting people in ways unrelated to getting the virus.

I’m thinking about the two options as being A) keeping the economy shut down as it is now for an unknown additional length of time, and B) re-opening the economy while strongly encouraging those who are vulnerable to continue staying at home and being very careful; people who can and want to work from home should do so; people who want to continue to self-isolate should do so; people should practice good hygiene and continue to watch for symptoms of being infected. So option B is to re-open all businesses and let people do what they believe is prudent for their own lives.

If we keep the economy shut down for some unknown additional length of time, the spread of the virus will continue to be slowed down because people are interacting with others less than if we re-open everything. It’s hard to say exactly how much higher the spread and the death rate would be if we opened up the economy sensibly as described above. The spread is already slowing. And everyone who needs hospitalization will be able to get it, plus we are discovering new treatments that seem to be effective. So I believe the benefit of keeping the economy shut down is modest at best.

The costs of keeping the economy shut down are both economic and health-related. So far, 22 million Americans are newly unemployed due to the shut downs. Unemployment has significant effects to mortality, and it’s not just about mental health, although that’s very important; death from numerous medical causes increases with unemployment; heart attack is just one example. Also consider the entrepreneurs who have worked hard and sacrificed over many years to build up their business, only to have everything taken away from them in the blink of an eye.

I’m hearing that the small business loan funds are drying up already. Many businesses will fold and some people will go bankrupt, lose their life savings, their homes, everything they have strived for because of the shut downs.

Another human cost of the shut downs is the cost of social isolation and the lack of meaningful social interactions. Research shows that this is as big a risk factor for poor health as smoking, obesity, high blood pressure, high cholesterol and lack of physical activity. I know that many people are making extra effort to stay connected to their loved ones and neighbors safely, to ward off the effects of social isolation. But not everyone has people reaching out to them in this way, and I don’t think we should completely dismiss the health effects of social isolation.

It is my opinion that the costs of continuing to keep America shut down are much higher, much worse than any modest benefits that might come from continuing the shut downs. Let’s open up Missouri and the rest of the country NOW.

–Gayle Brekke, Parkville

Tags: covid-19parkvilleplatte county
Landmark Staff

Landmark Staff

Related Posts

45 Years Ago–May 13, 1977

by Ivan Foley
May 13, 2022
0

Dr. Carl Myers purchase the Platte Medical Clinic in Platte City this week and plans to open his office here in the near future. Dr. Nourbaksh will continue to be located in the Platte Medical Clinic. Mr. and Mrs. Louis...

30 Years Ago–May 15, 1992

by Ivan Foley
May 13, 2022
0

Bob Foster, vice principal of Fort Osage Junior High in northeast Independence, has been hired as principal at West Platte High School in Weston. Two girls tied with the same grade point average have been declared valedictorians of the class...

15 Years Ago–May 9, 2007

by Ivan Foley
May 13, 2022
0

It has been a hectic week for Platte County residents and business owners with property in low-lying areas, as heavy rains across the region have forced rivers and streams out of their banks. Areas in and around Parkville, Riverside, Tracy...

The 80's

Kim Carnes and never buy gas on Tuesdays

by Ivan Foley
May 13, 2022
0

Gonna hit you with some pop culture stuff this week. Just because I want to. Season four of Ozark on Netflix. Have you finished it yet? Let's get through this without spoiling it for those who haven't made it all...

Next Post
COVID-19 Protest Rally

Protest rally

Popular News

  • Area distillery releases first new bourbon in 30 years

    Area distillery releases first new bourbon in 30 years

    22 shares
    Share 9 Tweet 6
  • Bee Creek Bridge replacement set

    10 shares
    Share 4 Tweet 3
  • Large logistics park planned east of I-29

    199 shares
    Share 80 Tweet 50
  • Memorial Day Weekend Celebration planned

    7 shares
    Share 3 Tweet 2
  • City extends lease on temporary police station

    7 shares
    Share 3 Tweet 2
  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Pickem Terms and Conditions
Call us at 816-858-0363

Copyright © 2019-2020 The Platte County Landmark Newspaper - All Rights Reserved

No Result
View All Result
  • Subscribe Online
  • Home
  • Local News
  • Opinion
  • Landmark Pickem
    • Results by Week
    • Pickem Rules and Help
  • Landmark Live!
  • Looking Backward
  • es_MXSpanish

Copyright © 2019-2020 The Platte County Landmark Newspaper - All Rights Reserved

Are you sure want to unlock this post?
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?