• About Us
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
Saturday, March 6, 2021
34 °f
Platte
57 ° Mon
61 ° Tue
63 ° Wed
54 ° Thu
The Platte County Landmark Newspaper
  • Home
  • Local News
  • Opinion
  • Landmark Live!
  • Looking Backward
  • Home
  • Local News
  • Opinion
  • Landmark Live!
  • Looking Backward
No Result
View All Result
The Platte County Landmark Newspaper
No Result
View All Result

Fired County HR worker wins appeal

Landmark Staff by Landmark Staff
May 2, 2010
in Platte County
3
SHARES
84
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare via Email

A day-and-a-half long appeal hearing to settle her unemployment claim ended positively for a fired Platte County human resources worker.

In addition to the positive news for the fired worker, details contained in the Missouri Division of Employment Security’s decision could signal another obstacle to the county in its civil lawsuit against the former worker. The verdict also further cut the credibility of a payroll specialist still employed in the county’s HR department.

RelatedNews

Republican women to meet via Zoom

Contractor chosen for new Buck O’Neil Bridge

Health department gets much less than requested

Kendra Montgomery was fired by the county last fall after being accused of falsifying time sheets. The county claims this alleged falsification resulted in Montgomery receiving more than $2,200 in unwarranted vacation time, medical leave and comp time between Jan. 16, 2008 until her dismissal in November 2009.

The county commission then filed a civil suit against Montgomery, which is still pending. Also, a criminal investigation was opened by law enforcement authorities after they read in The Landmark about the civil suit being filed.

An investigation by the Platte County Sheriff’s Department cleared Montgomery of any criminal wrongdoing. Platte County Prosecutor Eric Zahnd declined to press charges, saying “there was insufficient evidence to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that she had any criminal intent.”

Montgomery initially was denied unemployment on Dec. 24 after the state looked at the record and summarily made a ruling. Montgomery appealed that ruling with a filing on Jan. 21.

A telephone conference appeal hearing began on March 12. Montgomery participated and was also represented by her attorney, Mark Jess. Testifying for the county on that day was Bob Shaw, county counselor. After a half day, the matter was continued until April 5.

On April 5, the Missouri Division of Employment Security appeals tribunal heard the remainder of the appeal by telephone conference. The hearing continued through the entire day.

“It was probably the longest unemployment hearing in the history of the state of Missouri,” said Jim Plunkett, county commissioner.

BACKGROUND

Plunkett testified for the county, as did Matthew Gist, an attorney for the county’s insurance firm; Mary Robinson, county human resources director; and LeAnna Fannon, highly publicized payroll specialist for the county.

It was Fannon’s responses to a detective’s questioning that contributed heavily to authorities’ decision not to file charges against Montgomery.

Fannon admitted to detectives that she at one point had told Montgomery and other employees under her at the time that she was going to give them–and herself–an extra two weeks of paid vacation because the county commission had not awarded pay increases. Fannon’s testimony in the Montgomery unemployment hearing also worked against the county. The appeals tribunal in its ruling called Fannon’s testimony “not credible.” In its verdict, the appeals tribunal states: “The evidence presented by the employer is insufficient to show that the claimant (Montgomery) was responsible for any falsified time records or altered time records. It is further found that the testimony of one of the employer’s witnesses, the payroll specialist (Fannon), was not credible.”

Fannon has been in the news since last fall when the county auditor announced she was conducting an audit of the HR department due to what she said were problems with payroll and benefits. Siobhann Wiliams, county auditor, at the time alleged the county commission and others were not being cooperative in her attempt to audit the department. Commissioners disputed her claim, and during that time period announced that as part of their reaction to problems, Fannon had been demoted from a previous role as department head.

Fannon later filed a discrimination, harassment, and retaliation claim against Williams, alleging that Williams started the audit after Fannon had resisted alleged sexual advances from her. Williams vehemently denies the claim made by Fannon. Fannon’s claim is still pending at the Missouri Commission on Human Rights.

In her harassment claim, Fannon lists Montgomery as a witness. Fannon says Montgomery witnessed Williams peering at her through a window. Montgomery, however, in an interview with The Landmark last fall, said she believes the accusations Fannon is making against Williams “are false.”

In her counterclaim filed against the county, Montgomery says the county’s suit against her is “retaliation for her assertion of rights under the Family and Medical Leave Act and/or because she was named as a witness and was interviewed in LeAnna Fannon’s charge of discrimination against the county.”

Fannon did not return a Landmark phone call seeking comment on the verdict issued by the appeals tribunal. Robinson’s office said she is out of the office until Monday.

Montgomery’s attorneys declined to comment on the outcome of her unemployment appeal, citing the still-pending civil case.

THE HEARING

Montgomery worked for the county for two and a half years as a payroll specialist at a final rate of pay of $13.84. She was dismissed on Nov. 12 of last year.

The appeals tribunal wrote: “The employer’s director of human resources (Robinson) alleged that the claimant selected numerous time sheets for the period from May of 2009 through Nov. 12, 2009, which were not signed by her supervisor or were altered. She maintained that she had accumulated 90 hours of ‘comp time’ during that period and that on occasion she took time off in order to attend to foster care duties or court appearances.

“The claimant denied knowingly falsifying any time sheets. She maintained that other employees had access to her computer and that she believed that other employees had accessed her computer and had altered time records of the claimant and other employees.”

In siding with Montgomery and against the county, the appeals tribunal wrote: “The appeals tribunal notes that the evidence presented by the employer is insufficient to show that the claimant was responsible for any falsified time records or altered time records.”

The ruling continued: “It is further found that the testimony of one of the employers witnesses, the payroll specialist (Fannon), was not credible. The appeals tribunal further concludes that the other employees did have access to the claimant’s computer and therefore the time records of the employer.

“The appeals tribunal further concludes that the evidence presented by the employer is insufficient to show that the claimant was guilty of misconduct connected with her work.”

In reversing the determination of its deputy, the appeals tribunal writes: “It is concluded that the claimant was discharged from her employment on Nov. 13, 2009 but not for misconduct connected with her work.

“The deputy’s determination is reversed. The claimant is not disqualified for benefits.”

If the county chooses to appeal the ruling handed down by the tribunal, it has 30 days in which to file “an application for review.”



Tags: eric zahndLawsuitsplatte county
Landmark Staff

Landmark Staff

Related Posts

Platte Landing boat ramp described as ‘dangerous’

Platte Landing boat ramp described as ‘dangerous’

by Ivan Foley
March 4, 2021
0

In January of 2017 it is alleged Toni Anderson, age 20, a college student from Wichita who had been living and working in Kansas City, was driving her car when she got disoriented and ended up in the Platte Landing...

Joe Vanover

County commissioner wants to be associate circuit judge

by Ivan Foley
March 4, 2021
0

When Ann Hansbrough was recently appointed to fill the circuit judge post vacated by the retiring James Van Amburg, it created a vacancy in Hansbrough's former spot of associate circuit judge. The process to name the new associate circuit judge...

Government transparency

Lack of transparency at the health department

by Landmark Digital Staff
March 4, 2021
0

EDITOR: Something shady went down at the Platte County Health Department and it deserves to be investigated. Local dentist and board of trustees member, Teresa Hills, sold her dental practice and left Platte County on Jan. 1, 2021 requiring that...

Petticoat Junction

Commissioners, judgeships and Petticoat Junction

by Ivan Foley
March 4, 2021
0

Eight folks have applied to become associate circuit judge in Platte County. The chosen one will fill the spot vacated when Judge Ann Hansbrough was recently named to circuit judge, leaving her associate judgeship to be filled by a process...

Next Post

Ferguson named as judge for Riverside

Popular News

  • Platte Landing boat ramp described as ‘dangerous’

    Platte Landing boat ramp described as ‘dangerous’

    86 shares
    Share 34 Tweet 22
  • Why the urgency for R-3 bond issue?

    30 shares
    Share 12 Tweet 8
  • Judge tells city to produce documents

    23 shares
    Share 9 Tweet 6
  • County commissioner wants to be associate circuit judge

    15 shares
    Share 6 Tweet 4
  • City ‘finds’ 2,300 records, gives them to Jason Maki

    17 shares
    Share 7 Tweet 4
  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
Call us at 816-858-0363

Copyright © 2019-2020 The Platte County Landmark Newspaper - All Rights Reserved

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Subscribe Online
  • Local News
  • Opinion
  • Landmark Live!
  • Looking Backward

Copyright © 2019-2020 The Platte County Landmark Newspaper - All Rights Reserved

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Create New Account!

Fill the forms bellow to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist