• About Us
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Pickem Terms and Conditions
Wednesday, May 18, 2022
The Platte County Landmark Newspaper
  • Home
  • Local News
  • Opinion
  • Landmark Pickem!
    • Login / Sign-up
    • Results by Week
    • Pickem Rules and Help
  • Landmark Live!
  • Looking Backward
  • es_MXSpanish
  • Home
  • Local News
  • Opinion
  • Landmark Pickem!
    • Login / Sign-up
    • Results by Week
    • Pickem Rules and Help
  • Landmark Live!
  • Looking Backward
  • es_MXSpanish
No Result
View All Result
The Platte County Landmark Newspaper
No Result
View All Result

Platte City won’t appeal court’s Sunshine verdict

Ivan Foley by Ivan Foley
March 10, 2007
in Platte City
4
SHARES
95
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare via Email

No decision means no appeal. At least not yet.

At a special meeting Monday night, Platte City’s Board of Aldermen discussed the possibility of appealing the recent court decision that went against them in the Sunshine Law case brought by Harold Coons.

RelatedNews

Work begins at I-29 and Hwy. 92

Car shows set in Platte City

REAL ID enforcement pushed back to 2023

No official motions were made and no action taken, after discussion revealed three board members favored pursuing an appeal while three opposed.

The city has until March 12 to appeal the Jan. 31 decision by Platte County Circuit Court Judge Lee Hull. Hull’s ruling pulled the city’s two involuntary annexation questions off a scheduled Feb. 6 ballot.

The board is not scheduled to meet again until March 13, a day past the deadline. Another special meeting could always be called prior to the deadline, but there was no indication this week that another meeting would be planned.

Hull ruled the city violated the state’s open meetings law when the board discussed annexation and annexation boundaries in closed session last September. The judge ordered the city to pay $11,850 to Coons’ attorney, Bob Shaw.

Monday’s meeting featured mayor Dave Brooks’ soliciting comments from each of the six aldermen in regard to their individual feelings toward pursuing an appeal of Hull’s decision. Interestingly, the city’s annexation legal team of Williams and Campo was not present for the meeting.

Shaw, however, was sitting in the audience and several of the aldermen took the chance to be critical of him.

Alderman George McClintock opened the discussion.

“It is my strong belief that we did not in any way, shape or form break any laws. We were following the advice of our attorneys, who are very well-schooled in the Sunshine Law,” McClintock said.

McClintock said he feels a longtime resident, Coons, “was duped” into filing the lawsuit.

“I’m very upset about a person being used in this manner. I’m upset because Bob Shaw disallowed the citizens the right to determine the direction they want to go.

“I think we have good reason to pursue an appeal. We could go ahead and pursue an appeal and continue to look at annexation after the (April election when three board members are up for reelection).

“I don’t like to be on the losing side, particularly when I’m not at fault. But we’re dealing with public money. I’m not sitting here representing George McClintock. I’m representing the people of Platte City,” McClintock said, saying he would not favor an appeal because of the potential cost to the city.

The city’s attorneys estimated their legal fees to appeal the case could run “at least” $20,000, which alderman Kenneth Brown said “tells me it could be $30,000 or more.”

Alderman Bill Knighton said he favors appealing.

“My feeling is we need to appeal. I am not a liar,” Knighton said, not elaborating from where the reference to the word “liar” came.

Alderman Jim Palmer said he favors doing an appeal, citing a city survey that he claims showed 70% of respondents favored annexation.

“It’s our responsibility to take care of the people of Platte City,” Palmer stated.

Brown said he is not in favor of the idea. He was the first alderman to ask city administrator Keith Moody about the estimated legal costs to conduct the appeal. Brown also pointed out an appeal would drag the issue out another 9 or 10 months longer.

“Quite frankly, we need to get beyond this,” he said.

Brown added that spending $20,000 to $30,000 to appeal a judgment of less than $12,000 wouldn’t be good business.

“The cost outweighs the gain,” he noted.

Alderman Lee Roy Van Lew said he is “highly disappointed with the way this turned out. The judge has denied citizens the right to do this and that’s not right. I think we should go with the appeal.”

A little later, Van Lew said: “I hate to admit to being a liar,” without explanation for the use of the word.

“I don’t know that anybody is calling you a liar,” Brown told him.

Van Lew said if the city does not appeal, “Mr. Shaw will be unduly happy. I hope to God it affects him in his business.”

Alderman Aaron Jung opposed the idea of an appeal.

“Once you’ve taken an issue so far and gotten so much negative vibe. .. it’s a lawsuit that we may or may not win.”

The polling left Jung, Brown and McClintock opposed to an appeal, with Palmer, Knighton and Van Lew in favor.

Brooks declined to state an opinion publicly on his feelings about an appeal.

Shaw had a commitment to be in the Barry area later Monday evening and left city hall at the conclusion of the meeting. Reached Tuesday for comment, he said:

“I am very disappointed that some of the aldermen have chosen to make this a personal matter. I do not have any personal animosity to any of the aldermen. I disagree with their annexation policies and the way they have chosen to implement them.”

Shaw said his opposition to the city’s annexation should not have come as a surprise to the city officials.

“Several years ago I promised the mayor and the board of aldermen I would do everything in my power to stop their annexation plans. Now it appears they are upset that I kept my promise,” Shaw added.

Shaw said it would have made no sense for the city to pursue an appeal.

“It was disturbing to see that three members of the board of aldermen were willing to spend $20,000 to $30,000 of taxpayers’ money just to seek personal vindication. I would guess that the citizens of Platte City would prefer to see their money used for roads, parks or some of the city’s other pressing needs.

“Obviously, it makes no economic sense to spend $20,000 to $30,000 of taxpayers’ money to appeal a judgment for $11,000,” Shaw remarked.

Shaw said he is not happy about the way several aldermen have criticized his client Harold Coons, a longtime resident of the city.

“Several aldermen have chosen to insult one of their own citizens. This is particularly disturbing when you consider all that the Coons family has done for the city of Platte City throughout the years,” Shaw said.

Harold Coons’ father, Junior Coons, served as the city’s director of public works for many years. Junior Coons is also a past Truman Glenn Award winner for service to the community.

Land owned by Harold Coons’ father and brother had been targeted in the city’s involuntary annexation proposal and Coons was doing what he could to protect his family’s land, Shaw explained.

 

Tags: electionslawsuitLawsuitsplatte cityplatte countysunshine lawSunshine Laws
Ivan Foley

Ivan Foley

Ivan Foley, owner/publisher of the Platte County Landmark, has been on the news beat in Kansas City's Northland for 40 years. He provides weekly observations in his Between the Lines column and serves as host of Landmark Live, a light-hearted videocast featuring newsmakers in the Northland.

Related Posts

Budget, wars and tweets

Budget, wars and tweets

by Guy Speckman
May 13, 2022
0

The State of Missouri has passed a fiscal year budget. It nears $47 billion. Last year's budget was $36 billion. The largest budget increase in the history of the State of Missouri. If you still think Republicans are the fiscally...

45 Years Ago–May 13, 1977

by Ivan Foley
May 13, 2022
0

Dr. Carl Myers purchase the Platte Medical Clinic in Platte City this week and plans to open his office here in the near future. Dr. Nourbaksh will continue to be located in the Platte Medical Clinic. Mr. and Mrs. Louis...

30 Years Ago–May 15, 1992

by Ivan Foley
May 13, 2022
0

Bob Foster, vice principal of Fort Osage Junior High in northeast Independence, has been hired as principal at West Platte High School in Weston. Two girls tied with the same grade point average have been declared valedictorians of the class...

15 Years Ago–May 9, 2007

by Ivan Foley
May 13, 2022
0

It has been a hectic week for Platte County residents and business owners with property in low-lying areas, as heavy rains across the region have forced rivers and streams out of their banks. Areas in and around Parkville, Riverside, Tracy...

Next Post

Pocket park in Platte City will have historial theme

Popular News

  • Area distillery releases first new bourbon in 30 years

    Area distillery releases first new bourbon in 30 years

    22 shares
    Share 9 Tweet 6
  • Bee Creek Bridge replacement set

    10 shares
    Share 4 Tweet 3
  • Large logistics park planned east of I-29

    198 shares
    Share 79 Tweet 50
  • Memorial Day Weekend Celebration planned

    7 shares
    Share 3 Tweet 2
  • City extends lease on temporary police station

    7 shares
    Share 3 Tweet 2
  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Pickem Terms and Conditions
Call us at 816-858-0363

Copyright © 2019-2020 The Platte County Landmark Newspaper - All Rights Reserved

No Result
View All Result
  • Subscribe Online
  • Home
  • Local News
  • Opinion
  • Landmark Pickem
    • Results by Week
    • Pickem Rules and Help
  • Landmark Live!
  • Looking Backward
  • es_MXSpanish

Copyright © 2019-2020 The Platte County Landmark Newspaper - All Rights Reserved

Are you sure want to unlock this post?
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?